Publication: ครุธรรม 8 : สาเหตุของการเสื่อมสูญภิกษุณ
Submitted Date
Received Date
Accepted Date
Issued Date
2019
Copyright Date
Announcement No.
Application No.
Patent No.
Valid Date
Resource Type
Edition
Resource Version
Language
th
File Type
No. of Pages/File Size
ISBN
ISSN
2651-0502 (Online)
eISSN
DOI
Scopus ID
WOS ID
Pubmed ID
arXiv ID
item.page.harrt.identifier.callno
Other identifier(s)
Journal Title
วารสารมจรปรัชญาปริทรรศน
Volume
2
Issue
1
Edition
Start Page
44
End Page
60
Access Rights
Access Status
Rights
Rights Holder(s)
Physical Location
Bibliographic Citation
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Authors
Journal Issue
Title
ครุธรรม 8 : สาเหตุของการเสื่อมสูญภิกษุณ
Alternative Title(s)
The Eight Gurudhamma: The cause of the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni
Author(s)
Author’s Affiliation
Author's E-mail
Editor(s)
Editor’s Affiliation
Corresponding person(s)
Creator(s)
Compiler
Advisor(s)
Illustrator(s)
Applicant(s)
Inventor(s)
Issuer
Assignee
Other Contributor(s)
Series
Has Part
Abstract
บทความนี้ทําการศึกษาผลงานทางวรรณกรรมของหนังสือเรื่องเหตุเกิดพ.ศ. 1 เล่ม 1 และเล่ม 2 ซึ่งเขียนโดยพระเมตตานันโทภิกขุโดยเฉพาะการตีความเกี่ยวกับครุธรรม 8 กับการเสื่อมสูญของภิกษุณีเถรวาทซึ่งพระเมตตานันโทภิกขุตีความแตกต่างจากที่ปรากฏในพระไตรปิฎกโดยตีความว่าการบัญญัติครุธรรม 8 ไม่ใช่พุทธดํารัสมีแนวคิดที่เป็นอคติต่อสตรีอย่างรุนแรงและมีวัตถุประสงค์จะขจัดภิกษุณีสงฆ์ให้หมดไปบทความนี้ได้ศึกษากรณีดังกล่าวโดยศึกษาเป็น3 ประเด็นคือ 1. ครุธรรมกับการเป็นพุทธพจน์ 2. อคติทางเพศในพระพุทธศาสนาเถรวาท 3. เหตุปัจจัยแห่งความเสื่อมสูญของภิกษุณีเถรวาทในยุคหลังพุทธกาลจากหลักฐานและเหตุผลของนักวิชาการร่วมสมัยที่ศึกษาประเด็นดังกล่าวได้โต้แย้งหักล้างเหตุผลที่พระเมตตานันโทภิกขุนํามาแสดงไว้ทําให้การตีความของพระเมตตานันโทภิกขุไม่มีน้ําหนักเหตุผลเพียงพอที่จะยอมรับได้ว่าครุธรรม 8 ไม่ใช่พุทธดํารัสหรือเป็นสาเหตุของการเสื่อมสูญภิกษุณีสงฆ์
This article is the study of the famous book, It Happen in B.E. One, Vol.I and Vol.II by Venerable Mettanandho Bhikku, and viewpoints of the author. Especially the viewpoints of Gurudhamma and the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkuni, in which Buddhism is interpreted and explained through scientific frameworks. In the case of The Eight Gurudhamma is the cause of the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni, the author ahows that The Eight Gurudhamma is not the words of the Buddha. It happens after the increase of bhikkhuni by the powerful bhikkhu at that time, which regard and treat bhikkhuni as a mere adjunct of man, with an aim to eliminate Theravada Bhikkhuni. This article studies the viewpoint of the author and the other educators in three points. 1. The Eight Gurudhamma and the word of the Buddha. 2. Feminism in Theravada Buddhism. 3. The cause of the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni after the parinibbana of the Buddha. From the viewpoint of many educators show the reasons to argue the interpretations of the author, the fault in which Buddhism is interpreted and explained through scientific frameworks, such as, Einstein’s theory of relativity and Mahapadesa, the status and the roles played by the women during the Buddha’s life and feminism, also the historic reason to assist the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni after the parinibbana of the Buddha. Significantly, the reason of many educators reduces the weight to rely on the interpretation of the author. Absolutely, the interpretation of the author not to be in line with the Tipitaka. Therefore, The Eight Gurudhamma is the words of the Buddha, and is not exactly the cause of the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni.
This article is the study of the famous book, It Happen in B.E. One, Vol.I and Vol.II by Venerable Mettanandho Bhikku, and viewpoints of the author. Especially the viewpoints of Gurudhamma and the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkuni, in which Buddhism is interpreted and explained through scientific frameworks. In the case of The Eight Gurudhamma is the cause of the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni, the author ahows that The Eight Gurudhamma is not the words of the Buddha. It happens after the increase of bhikkhuni by the powerful bhikkhu at that time, which regard and treat bhikkhuni as a mere adjunct of man, with an aim to eliminate Theravada Bhikkhuni. This article studies the viewpoint of the author and the other educators in three points. 1. The Eight Gurudhamma and the word of the Buddha. 2. Feminism in Theravada Buddhism. 3. The cause of the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni after the parinibbana of the Buddha. From the viewpoint of many educators show the reasons to argue the interpretations of the author, the fault in which Buddhism is interpreted and explained through scientific frameworks, such as, Einstein’s theory of relativity and Mahapadesa, the status and the roles played by the women during the Buddha’s life and feminism, also the historic reason to assist the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni after the parinibbana of the Buddha. Significantly, the reason of many educators reduces the weight to rely on the interpretation of the author. Absolutely, the interpretation of the author not to be in line with the Tipitaka. Therefore, The Eight Gurudhamma is the words of the Buddha, and is not exactly the cause of the disappearance of Theravada Bhikkhuni.