Publication: Agency and Belief Is Kamma "Natural"? Appraising Julia Cassaniti's Argument
Submitted Date
Received Date
Accepted Date
Issued Date
2018
Copyright Date
Announcement No.
Application No.
Patent No.
Valid Date
Resource Type
Edition
Resource Version
Language
en
File Type
No. of Pages/File Size
ISBN
ISSN
eISSN
DOI
Scopus ID
WOS ID
Pubmed ID
arXiv ID
item.page.harrt.identifier.callno
Other identifier(s)
Journal Title
Journal of International Buddhist Studies
Volume
9
Issue
1
Edition
Start Page
78
End Page
100
Access Rights
Access Status
Rights
Rights Holder(s)
Physical Location
Bibliographic Citation
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Authors
Journal Issue
Title
Agency and Belief Is Kamma "Natural"? Appraising Julia Cassaniti's Argument
Alternative Title(s)
Author(s)
Author’s Affiliation
Author's E-mail
Editor(s)
Editor’s Affiliation
Corresponding person(s)
Creator(s)
Compiler
Advisor(s)
Illustrator(s)
Applicant(s)
Inventor(s)
Issuer
Assignee
Other Contributor(s)
Series
Has Part
Abstract
In this paper I am assessing Julia Cassaniti’s (2012, 2015) claim that Buddhists in Thailand perceive religious concepts (specifically "kamma") as natural entities, comparable to natural laws. Her claim is based on, and intended to lend empirical support to, Don Handelman's thesis that formal character of cosmologies determines the emphasis a religious tradition puts on "belief". Cassaniti expands on the thesis proposing that cosmology and belief are connected through people's representation of agency. I am arguing that Cassaniti misrepresents the relationship between public discourse and real representations of religious concepts and, more specifically, discounts cultural conventions informing the Thai way of using langue. Thai religious and cultural practices also clearly indicate a situation incongruent with Cassaniti's assertion that agency is perceived by Thai Buddhist as inherent to the acting subject which is fully responsible for both its present actions and their broader, kammically determined, cosmological context. Lastly, I am pointing out some problems related to her analysis of data collected through interviews.